When Real Support Looks Fake: Why proof of people matters as new leaders take office

By: Liz Underwood and Courtney Cox

In January, a new Congress convenes. Across the country, newly elected governors and state legislators are also taking office, bringing new leadership and priorities to state government. Many will be stepping into their roles for the first time. They’ll soon be reading letters, emails, and public comments from constituents with one question  becoming increasingly important: Is this real? 

They have reason to wonder. This spring, New York lawmakers received hundreds to thousands of form emails backing a state insurance proposal. Some constituents said they never sent the emails filed under their names, and one arrived from a woman who died in 2015. This is just one example. Last fall, county commissioners in North Carolina received hundreds of emails supporting a proposed gas pipeline. When they wrote back, constituents said they had never sent them. 

These aren't isolated incidents. Among every threat facing the world, the World Economic Forum ranks misinformation and disinformation the No. 2 global risk of the next two years. 

There's another side to this problem, though. As decision makers become more skeptical about manufactured support, what happens to the voices of people who genuinely want to be heard? 

When Real Support Gets Dismissed 

In the 2027 M.Cast™ Trends Report, we flagged fake consensus as a risk even bigger than fake content. Leaders may misread the moment and overcorrect, underreact, or bend to manufactured pressure.  

The report also warned of the reverse. As trust erodes across the board, genuine support can get swept out with the fakes. A wave of authentic constituent stories can look like a bot campaign. For any issue that depends on public support, being heard now requires being believed. 

What Makes Support Credible 

Credibility starts with the people behind the message. Much of advocacy is organized, and for good reason. People with a genuine stake in an issue who want their voices heard often need help bringing their perspectives to decision makers.  

A few principles guide how Moore builds support that holds up. 

Make room for different kinds of participation. Some people will sign a letter. Others will testify, sit for an interview, or write an op-ed. A strong network makes room for all of them. 

Make it personal. A well-crafted message carries the most weight when it’s grounded in the speaker’s own experience, such as a homeowner describing what changed on their street. 

Show up in ways that can be verified. Bots can flood a comment portal or a hashtag. They can’t testify in committee, meet with a policymaker, or write a column in the local paper. In-person and earned channels are where an authentic voice is easiest to prove. 

Build partnerships around shared priorities.  Partner with established organizations and community leaders who have a genuine stake in the issue. The strongest partnerships are built on shared priorities with stakeholders who maintain their independence and provide a meaningful voice in the work. 

What to Watch 

Platforms and policymakers have started looking for ways to ensure real people stand behind public input. In July, Meta began rolling out Facebook Verified in select markets, a free badge that verifies an account belongs to a human. That same month, a House committee advanced the Comment Integrity and Management Act, which aims to verify that comments on federal rules come from actual people. These developments are worth watching. But verifying that someone is a real person is only part of the equation. What also matters is whether that person took action and shared their own perspective. 

Authentic advocacy begins with relationships built long before the first committee meeting. At Moore, we’ve spent years building relationships with the people closest to our clients’ issues, so when the moment comes, we’re engaging real people who have a genuine stake in the outcome. 

Ready to build support that stands up to scrutiny? Let’s talk.